Advanced Search

Journal Navigation

Journal Home

Subscriptions

Archive

Contact Us

Table of Contents

Click here to sign up for SAGE Journal Email Alerts today!

Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
Educational Researcher
This Article
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow References
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to Saved Citations
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowRequest Permissions
Right arrow Request Reprints
Right arrow Add to My Marked Citations
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Right arrow Citing Articles via Scopus
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by SMITH, J. K.
Right arrow Articles by HESHUSIUS, L.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
Social Bookmarking
 Add to CiteULike   Add to Complore   Add to Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us   Add to Digg   Add to Reddit   Add to Technorati   Add to Twitter  
What's this?

Closing Down the Conversation: The End of the Quantitative-Qualitative Debate Among Educational Inquirers

JOHN K. SMITH

University of Northern Iowa

LOUS HESHUSIUS

York University

The contention of this paper is that the claim of compatibility and the call for cooperation between quantitative and qualitative inquiry cannot be sustained. Moreover, these claims have the unfortunate effect of closing down an important conversation. To elaborate these points, this paper briefly reviews the transition from conflict to cooperation between the two perspectives and then notes how compatibility is based on a confusion over two different definitions of method. Finally, the discussion focuses on why this conversation, because it invokes issues crucial to our understanding of who we are and what we do as inquirers, must be reinvigorated.

Educational Researcher, Vol. 15, No. 1, 4-12 (1986)
DOI: 10.3102/0013189X015001004


Add to CiteULike CiteULike   Add to Complore Complore   Add to Connotea Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us Del.icio.us   Add to Digg Digg   Add to Reddit Reddit   Add to Technorati Technorati   Add to Twitter Twitter    What's this?


This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional ChildrenHome page
C. C. Griffin, A. K. Jitendra, and M. B. League
Novice Special Educators' Instructional Practices, Communication Patterns, and Content Knowledge for Teaching Mathematics
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children, November 1, 2009; 32(4): 319 - 336.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
PedagogyHome page
N. L. Chick, H. Hassel, and A. Haynie
"Pressing an Ear against the Hive": Reading Literature for Complexity
Pedagogy, October 1, 2009; 9(3): 399 - 422.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Qualitative InquiryHome page
K. R. Howe
Isolating Science from the Humanities: The Third Dogma of Educational Research
Qualitative Inquiry, April 1, 2009; 15(4): 766 - 784.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Urban EducationHome page
P. A. Junor Clarke and C. D. Thomas
Teachers' Perceptions of Connections and Disconnects Between Their Alternative Preparation and Teaching in Urban Classrooms
Urban Education, March 1, 2009; 44(2): 144 - 159.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
H. Borko, J. Whitcomb, and D. Liston
Wicked Problems and Other Thoughts on Issues of Technology and Teacher Learning
Journal of Teacher Education, January 1, 2009; 60(1): 3 - 7.
[PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
R. Santagata
Designing Video-Based Professional Development for Mathematics Teachers in Low-Performing Schools
Journal of Teacher Education, January 1, 2009; 60(1): 38 - 51.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Qualitative InquiryHome page
M. Hammersley
Closing Down the Conversation? A Reply to Smith and Hodkinson
Qualitative Inquiry, January 1, 2009; 15(1): 40 - 48.
[PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
D. Loewenberg Ball, M. H. Thames, and G. Phelps
Content Knowledge for Teaching: What Makes It Special?
Journal of Teacher Education, November 1, 2008; 59(5): 389 - 407.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Family IssuesHome page
V. L. Plano Clark, C. A. Huddleston-Casas, S. L. Churchill, D. O'Neil Green, and A. L. Garrett
Mixed Methods Approaches in Family Science Research
Journal of Family Issues, November 1, 2008; 29(11): 1543 - 1566.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Music Teacher EducationHome page
J. Si Millican
A New Framework for Music Education Knowledge and Skill
Journal of Music Teacher Education, October 1, 2008; 18(1): 67 - 78.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
European Physical Education ReviewHome page
M. Kovac, S. Sloan, and G. Starc
Competencies in physical education teaching: Slovenian teachers' views and future perspectives
European Physical Education Review, October 1, 2008; 14(3): 299 - 323.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Educational and Psychological MeasurementHome page
N. Kersting
Using Video Clips of Mathematics Classroom Instruction as Item Prompts to Measure Teachers' Knowledge of Teaching Mathematics
Educational and Psychological Measurement, October 1, 2008; 68(5): 845 - 861.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
T. Konold, B. Jablonski, A. Nottingham, L. Kessler, S. Byrd, S. Imig, R. Berry, and R. McNergney
Adding Value to Public Schools: Investigating Teacher Education, Teaching, and Pupil Learning
Journal of Teacher Education, September 1, 2008; 59(4): 300 - 312.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Cultural Studies <=> Critical MethodologiesHome page
J. K. Smith and D. J. Gallagher
An Essay on the Politics of Schooling and Educational Research
Cultural Studies <=> Critical Methodologies, August 1, 2008; 8(3): 284 - 301.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Mixed Methods ResearchHome page
E. E. Jang, D. E. McDougall, D. Pollon, M. Herbert, and P. Russell
Integrative Mixed Methods Data Analytic Strategies in Research on School Success in Challenging Circumstances
Journal of Mixed Methods Research, July 1, 2008; 2(3): 221 - 247.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Language Teaching ResearchHome page
E. Gatbonton
Looking beyond teachers' classroom behaviour: Novice and experienced ESL teachers' pedagogical knowledge
Language Teaching Research, April 1, 2008; 12(2): 161 - 182.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Public Understanding of ScienceHome page
O. Bozkurt and O. Nafiz Kaya
Teaching about ozone layer depletion in Turkey: pedagogical content knowledge of science teachers.
Public Understanding of Science, April 1, 2008; 17(2): 261 - 276.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
PedagogyHome page
C. M. Tremonte and L. Racioppi
At the Interstices: Postcolonial Literary Studies Meets International Relations
Pedagogy, January 1, 2008; 8(1): 43 - 73.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Music Teacher EducationHome page
W. Haston and A. Leon-Guerrero
Sources of Pedagogical Content Knowledge: Reports by Preservice Instrumental Music Teachers
Journal of Music Teacher Education, January 1, 2008; 17(2): 48 - 59.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Educational PolicyHome page
H. C. Hill and S. T. Lubienski
Teachers' Mathematics Knowledge for Teaching and School Context: A Study of California Teachers
Educational Policy, November 1, 2007; 21(5): 747 - 768.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Music Educators JournalHome page
J. Wiggins
Authentic Practice and Process in Music Teacher Education
Music Educators Journal, January 1, 2007; 93(3): 36 - 42.
[PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
S. C. Yanchar and D. D. Williams
Reconsidering the Compatibility Thesis and Eclecticism: Five Proposed Guidelines for Method Use
Educational Researcher, December 1, 2006; 35(9): 3 - 12.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Adv. Physiol. Educ.Home page
V. D. O'Loughlin
A "how to" guide for developing a publishable Scholarship of Teaching project
Advan Physiol Educ, June 1, 2006; 30(2): 83 - 88.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Marketing ScienceHome page
S. M. Shugan
Editorial: Save Research--Abandon the Case Method of Teaching
Marketing Science, March 1, 2006; 25(2): 109 - 115.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
International Journal of Music EducationHome page
M. J. Bergee
An exploratory comparison of novice, intermediate, and expert orchestral conductors
International Journal of Music Education, April 1, 2005; 23(1): 23 - 36.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Positive Behavior InterventionsHome page
W. Sailor and J. L. Paul
Framing Positive Behavior Support in the Ongoing Discourse Concerning the Politics of Knowledge
Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, January 1, 2004; 6(1): 37 - 49.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Special EducationHome page
L. M. Stough and D. J. Palmer
Special Thinking in Special Settings: A Qualitative Study of Expert Special Educators
Journal of Special Education, January 1, 2003; 36(4): 206 - 222.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Qual Health ResHome page
S. I. Miller and M. Fredericks
Naturalistic Inquiry and Reliabilism: A Compatible Epistemological Grounding
Qual Health Res, September 1, 2002; 12(7): 982 - 989.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Early InterventionHome page
S. Li, J. M. Marquart, and C. Zercher
Conceptual Issues and Analytic Strategies in Mixed-Method Studies of Preschool Inclusion
Journal of Early Intervention, April 1, 2000; 23(2): 116 - 132.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
A. Roychoudhury and J. B. Kahle
Science Teaching in the Middle Grades: Policy Implications for Teacher Education and Systemic Reform
Journal of Teacher Education, September 1, 1999; 50(4): 278 - 289.
[PDF]


Home page
Journal of Special EducationHome page
N. Mamlin
Despite Best Intentions: When Inclusion Fails
Journal of Special Education, April 1, 1999; 33(1): 36 - 49.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
REVIEW OF RESEARCH IN EDUCATIONHome page
K. R. HOWE and M. S. MOSES
Chapter 2: Ethics in Educational Research
Review of Research in Education, January 1, 1999; 24(1): 21 - 59.
[PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
K. R. Howe
The Interpretive Turn and the New Debate in Education
Educational Researcher, November 1, 1998; 27(8): 13 - 20.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
M. Hammersley
Telling Tales About Educational Research: A Response to John K. Smith
Educational Researcher, October 1, 1998; 27(7): 18 - 21.
[PDF]


Home page
Qual Health ResHome page
D. L. Morgan
Practical Strategies for Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Methods: Applications to Health Research
Qual Health Res, May 1, 1998; 8(3): 362 - 376.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional ChildrenHome page
L. K. Elksnin
Use of the Case Method of Instruction in Special Education Teacher Preparation Programs: A Preliminary Investigation
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children, April 1, 1998; 21(2): 95 - 108.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
J. K. Smith
The Stories Educational Researchers Tell About Themselves
Educational Researcher, June 1, 1997; 26(5): 4 - 11.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional ChildrenHome page
A. Cranston-Gingras, S. Raines, J. Paul, B. Epancbin, and H. Rosselli
Developing and Using Teaching Cases in a Partnership Environment
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children, April 1, 1996; 19(2): 158 - 168.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
RELC JournalHome page
J. C Richards, B. Li, and A. Tang
A Comparison of Pedagogical Reasoning Skills in Novice and Experienced Esl Teachers
RELC Journal, December 1, 1995; 26(2): 1 - 24.
[PDF]


Home page
Remedial and Special EducationHome page
E. P. SCHILLER, D. B. MALOUF, and L. C. DANIELSON
Research Utilization A Federal Perspective
Remedial and Special Education, November 1, 1995; 16(6): 372 - 375.
[PDF]


Home page
Journal of Special EducationHome page
W. D. Eiserman, C. Weber, and M. McCoun
Parent and Professional Roles in Early Intervention: A Longitudinal Comparison of the Effects of two Intervention Configurations
Journal of Special Education, January 1, 1995; 29(1): 20 - 44.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
G. Delandshere and A. R. Petrosky
Capturing Teachers' Knowledge: Performance Assessment: a) and Post-Structuralist Epistemology * b) From a Post-Structuralist Perspective * c) and Post-Structuralism * d) None of the Above
Educational Researcher, June 1, 1994; 23(5): 11 - 18.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Remedial and Special EducationHome page
D. L. Ferguson
Something a Little Out of the Ordinary: Reflections on Becoming an Interpretivist Researcher in Special Education
Remedial and Special Education, July 1, 1993; 14(4): 35 - 43.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Am Educ Res JHome page
G. D. Kuh
In Their Own Words: What Students Learn Outside the Classroom
American Educational Research Journal, January 1, 1993; 30(2): 277 - 304.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION AND POLICY ANALYSISHome page
V. J. Caracelli and J. C. Greene
Data Analysis Strategies for Mixed-Method Evaluation Designs
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, January 1, 1993; 15(2): 195 - 207.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Educational Administration QuarterlyHome page
W. L. Boyd
The Power of Paradigms: Reconceptualizing Educational Policy and Management
Educational Administration Quarterly, November 1, 1992; 28(4): 504 - 528.
[Abstract]


Home page
Journal of the Academy of Marketing ScienceHome page
T. B. Heath
The Reconciliation of Humanism and Positivism in the Practice of Consumer Research: A View from the Trenches
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, March 1, 1992; 20(2): 107 - 118.
[Abstract]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
G. Salomon
Transcending the Qualitative-Quantitative Debate: The Analytic and Systemic Approaches to Educational Research
Educational Researcher, August 1, 1991; 20(6): 10 - 18.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
S. I. MILLER and M. FREDERICKS
Postpositivistic Assumptions and Educational Research: Another View
Educational Researcher, May 1, 1991; 20(4): 2 - 8.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
M. Cochran-Smith
Reinventing Student Teaching
Journal of Teacher Education, March 1, 1991; 42(2): 104 - 118.
[Abstract]


Home page
REVIEW OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHHome page
R. T. Ogawa and B. Malen
Towards Rigor in Reviews of Multivocal Literatures: Applying the Exploratory Case Study Method
Review of Educational Research, January 1, 1991; 61(3): 265 - 286.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
C. Edelsky
Whose Agenda Is This Anyway? A Response to McKenna, Robinson, and Miller
Educational Researcher, November 1, 1990; 19(8): 7 - 11.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Remedial and Special EducationHome page
H. Borko, C. Livingston, and R. J. Shavelson
Teachers' Thinking About Instruction
Remedial and Special Education, November 1, 1990; 11(6): 40 - 49.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Gifted Child QuarterlyHome page
J. H. Borland
Postpositivist Inquiry: Implications of the "New Philosophy of Science" for the Field of the Education of the Gifted
Gifted Child Quarterly, October 1, 1990; 34(4): 161 - 167.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
P. B. Clarridge
Multiple Perspectives on the Classroom Performance of Certified and Uncertified Teachers
Journal of Teacher Education, September 1, 1990; 41(4): 15 - 25.
[Abstract]


Home page
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional ChildrenHome page
H. A. Rude and P. A. Lee
Identification of Promising Future Special Education Teachers Through a Needs-Based Perspective
Teacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children, July 1, 1990; 13(3-4): 175 - 181.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
K. Howe and M. Eisenhart
Standards for Qualitative (and Quantitative) Research: A Prolegomenon
Educational Researcher, May 1, 1990; 19(4): 2 - 9.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
E. Goldman and L. Barron
Using Hypermedia to Improve the Preparation of Elementary Teachers
Journal of Teacher Education, May 1, 1990; 41(3): 21 - 31.
[Abstract]


Home page
J Learn DisabilHome page
L. Heshusius
Holistic Principles: Not Enhancing the Old but Seeing A-new. A Rejoinder
J Learn Disabil, December 1, 1989; 22(10): 595 - 601.
[PDF]


Home page
J Learn DisabilHome page
L. Heshusius
The Newtonian Mechanistic Paradigm, Special Education, and Contours of Alternatives: An Overview
J Learn Disabil, August 1, 1989; 22(7): 403 - 415.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
C. Livingston and H. Borko
Expert-Novice Differences in Teaching: A Cognitive Analysis and Implications for Teacher Education
Journal of Teacher Education, July 1, 1989; 40(4): 36 - 42.
[Abstract]


Home page
Family and Consumer Sciences Research JournalHome page
R. E. Martin and R. Chaudhary
Teachers' Perceptions of Instructional Planning Skills: Development of a Scale
Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal, June 1, 1989; 17(4): 351 - 358.
[Abstract]


Home page
Educational Administration QuarterlyHome page
R. K. Wimpelberg, C. Teddlie, and S. Stringfield
Sensitivity to Context: The Past and Future of Effective Schools Research
Educational Administration Quarterly, February 1, 1989; 25(1): 82 - 107.
[Abstract]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION AND POLICY ANALYSISHome page
J. C. Greene, V. J. Caracelli, and W. F. Graham
Toward a Conceptual Framework for Mixed-Method Evaluation Designs
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, January 1, 1989; 11(3): 255 - 274.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
REVIEW OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHHome page
Y. S. Lincoln
Qualitative Research: A Response to Atkinson, Delamont, and Hammersley
Review of Educational Research, January 1, 1989; 59(2): 237 - 239.
[PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
K. R. Howe
Against the Quantitative-Qualitative Incompatibility Thesis or Dogmas Die Hard
Educational Researcher, November 1, 1988; 17(8): 10 - 16.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
D. M. Fetterman
Qualitative Approaches to Evaluating Education
Educational Researcher, November 1, 1988; 17(8): 17 - 23.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
L. Valli and A. R. Tom
How Adequate are the Knowledge Base Frameworks in Teacher Education?
Journal of Teacher Education, September 1, 1988; 39(5): 5 - 12.
[Abstract]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
A. C. Porter
Understanding Teaching: A Model for Assessment
Journal of Teacher Education, July 1, 1988; 39(4): 2 - 7.
[Abstract]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
S. Hollingsworth
Making Field-Based Programs Work: A Three-Level Approach to Reading Education
Journal of Teacher Education, July 1, 1988; 39(4): 28 - 36.
[Abstract]


Home page
West J Nurs ResHome page
J. E. Haase and S. T. Myers
Reconciling Paradigm Assumptions of Qualitative and Quantitative Research
West J Nurs Res, April 1, 1988; 10(2): 128 - 137.
[PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
J. K. Smith
The Evaluator/Researcher as Person vs. the Person as Evaluator/Researcher
Educational Researcher, March 1, 1988; 17(2): 18 - 23.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Remedial and Special EducationHome page
M. S. Poplin
Self-Imposed Blindness: The Scientific Method in Education
Remedial and Special Education, November 1, 1987; 8(6): 31 - 37.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Remedial and Special EducationHome page
J. M. Kauffman
Research in Special Education: A Commentary
Remedial and Special Education, November 1, 1987; 8(6): 57 - 62.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
W. A. FIRESTONE
Meaning in Method: The Rhetoric of Quantitative and Qualitative Research
Educational Researcher, October 1, 1987; 16(7): 16 - 21.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
Assessment for Effective InterventionHome page
B. A. Guy and H. E. Knowlton
Assessing Transition: An Inquiry Concerning Decision Making
Assessment for Effective Intervention, January 1, 1987; 12(3-4): 192 - 204.
[Abstract] [PDF]


Home page
EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERHome page
S. Miller
Letters: Some Comments on Keeping the Quantitative-Qualitative Debate Open
Educational Researcher, November 1, 1986; 15(9): 24 - 25.
[PDF]


Home page
Journal of Teacher EducationHome page
W. D. Hawley
A Critical Analysis of The Holmes Group's for Reforming Teacher Education: Holmes Report
Journal of Teacher Education, July 1, 1986; 37(4): 47 - 51.




AER home page RER home page EPA home page JEB home page RRE home page